Skip to content

Letter grades

  • P — Pass
  • R — Partial pass
  • F — Fail
  • U — Unknown

Accountability

PPass — To pass, the data center publishes its water, electricity, and noise numbers before the vote, names an ambassador the town can call, and states a water limit the town can hold it to. A study that arrives after the vote is not that limit.

FFail — A failing grade is assigned when there is no named ambassador, when the water, electricity, or noise numbers are not public, or when water is left as a study with no limit.

  • Public ambassador

    In order to pass, the data center must have a named ambassador to field questions and act as a company representative to the public.

  • Water

    The water equation has two parts. The first is the gallons of water required to cool the data center. The second is the number of gallons required to cool an on-site power plant. Publishing those gallons is not enough. A passing project states a limit the town can hold it to, before the vote.

  • Electricity

    The electricity number is the megawatts the data center will use, and the utility that will supply them. That number has to be public. Who pays for the power is a separate test.

  • Noise

    The noise number is the level at the nearest homes. It has to be published before the vote, not after neighbors start to complain.

Power

PPass — To pass, a data center must legally commit to provide all of its own power, on site or at a remote power station. Households must be held harmless from any increase in rates.

FFail — A failing grade is assigned when a company uses only local electricity without providing additional generation. It is also assigned when the plan does not describe how the electricity is paid for.

  • On-site power

    The campus builds its own power and pays for it.

  • Distant power

    The power comes from somewhere else. Temporary power on the site is allowed while the transmission lines are built.

  • A rate subsidy

    If household bills rise while that power is being built, the company pays the difference. Households do not.

Tax

PPass — To pass, the project pays the full tax, with no special break from the city, the county, or the state. The tax break, any reimbursement, and any cost the city would carry are public before the vote.

FFail — A failing grade is assigned when the deal includes a credit, a reimbursement, or any arrangement that hands the tax money back.

Commitment

PPass — To pass, the company puts money, or something it builds, on the public record for the town, and that commitment lasts for years.

FFail — A failing grade is assigned when the offer is only talk about jobs, or when the money goes back to the company.

  • Power and water

    The company pays for local power and water so households do not have to.

  • Parks

    The company pays for parks the town already needed.

  • Roads

    The company pays for roads the campus will wear out.

  • A training place

    The company builds a place in town where people can learn the tools.

  • Credits and classes

    The company pays for credits and classes for people who live there.